Tidy Pudding Ideas: Sticky Coffee Pudding

Tidy Pudding Ideas: Sticky Coffee Pudding

We’ve been back in the kitchen, creating more delicious recipes with some of the best Welsh food and drink (in our opinion!).

Back in September, we attended the Abergavenny Food Festival, alongside our friends at Shirgar Butter! After lots of fun and conversations, we wondered whether we could incorporate this iconic Welsh brand into one of our recipes. 

Of course, the answer is yes. And you just have to try this Sticky Coffee Pudding.

We’ve given this traditional dessert a tidy upgrade. Can you think of anything more tempting than a moist coffee sponge smothered in rich, glossy butterscotch sauce? 

This pudding is made with our Tidy Coffee and creamy Welsh butter from Shirgar, which is churned and packaged just down the road in Carmarthenshire. Some would say it’s a match made in Wales!

See the full recipe below, or head over to our socials to watch us make it!

Ingredients:

For the sponge:

  • 200g of dates (pitted)
  • 200ml of Hot Tidy Coffee Bags (we used two bags to brew!)
  • 85g of melted Shirgar Unsalted Welsh Butter 
  • 190g of light brown sugar
  • 275g of self-raising flour
  • 1 tsp of bicarbonate of soda
  • 1 tsp of baking powder
  • 80g of black treacle
  • 3 medium eggs
  • 100ml whole milk

If you prefer not to use caffeine in the recipe, we also have decaf coffee bags available. 

For your buttery butterscotch sauce:

  • 75g of Shirgar Unsalted Welsh Butter 
  • 90g of light brown sugar
  • 1 tbsp of black treacle
  • 100ml of brewed Tidy Coffee Bags
  • 150ml of double cream

To make your Sticky Coffee Pudding, follow these steps:

  1. Cut your dates up as finely as possible 
  2. Get two Tidy Coffee Bags and brew in 200ml of boiling water for at least 5 mins, before removing the bags.
  3. Soak your chopped dates in the hot coffee for at least 20 mins 
  4. In a separate bowl, melt your Shirgar Butter and add the rest of your sponge ingredients except the dates mixture. 
  5. Give a good mix until well combined
  6. Add in your soaked dates and the coffee mixture; no need to drain! 
  7. Mix your dates into the sponge mixture until well combined.
  8. Butter a large dish; we used a 30 x 20cm one, and pour in your mixture.
  9. Bake at 180 degrees for 30-45 minutes, checking in regularly to catch the moment when it's no longer wobbly and a knife comes out clean.
  10. Whilst your cake is in the oven, add all of your sauce ingredients to a saucepan and place on a medium heat.
  11. Stir constantly for 5 mins or until simmering
  12. Leave to simmer for 1-2 minutes until thickened slightly. 
  13. Remove from heat and place to one side
  14. Once your cake is baked, serve up immediately with plenty of the sauce and a scoop of ice cream or custard

Get your ingredients!

This really is the go-to recipe for cosy season. It’s the perfect dessert for your Roast Dinner, or maybe you fancy a Saturday afternoon treat with a warming cup of Welsh Black Tea and your favourite winter movie.  

Head over to our shop to purchase your coffee bags (or decaf coffee bags) for this recipe. 

Give it a go and let us know what you think! Make sure you follow us on TikTok and Instagram for pudding ideas, recipes and serving suggestions for a Tidy brew. 

Back to blog